Bloomerang is great at donor retention — for organizations that have the staff, the budget, and the time to invest. SmartChange is great at getting you raising money before you finish your morning coffee.
This is the question that matters — and most comparison pages skip it entirely.
SmartChange is an all-in-one fundraising platform for nonprofits, PTAs, educational organizations, nonpartisan campaigns, NIL collectives, NIL athletes, and crisis fundraising. Same-day launch, no monthly fees on Standard, Growth, or Pro, donor fee coverage (90%+ adoption), Spare Change round-ups, peer-to-peer fundraising, and a full public API from day one. Built for organizations that need to start raising now. Operated by Level Wins in Little Rock, Arkansas.
Bloomerang is a nonprofit donor management CRM built around donor retention — engagement scoring, lapsed donor identification, constituent timelines, and retention benchmarking. It includes online fundraising tools, email communications, and reporting. Bloomerang requires a monthly subscription that scales with database size and has an onboarding process for new organizations. Best suited to nonprofits with dedicated fundraising staff focused on long-term donor relationship management.
| Feature | SmartChange | Bloomerang |
|---|---|---|
| Time to First Fundraiser | Under 15 minutes | Days to weeks (setup + import required) |
| Monthly Fees | None on Standard, Growth, or Pro | Required — starts ~$125+/mo, scales with DB size |
| Processing Fee | 3.75% + 25¢ per transaction | Processing fees apply; varies by plan and processor |
| Donor Fee Coverage | Yes — 90%+ adoption; 0–1% effective rate | Not a distinct feature |
| Platform Tip Prompts | Never | Not applicable |
| Setup Process | Self-serve, same-day, no tech team | Onboarding, database import, configuration |
| Donor Retention Scoring | Not available | Yes — core differentiator |
| Constituent Timelines | Not available | Yes — full interaction history |
| Donor CRM | CRM-Lite — profiles, giving history, segments | Full enterprise donor management CRM |
| Peer-to-Peer Fundraising | Yes — all plans | Yes |
| Recurring Donations | Yes — all plans | Yes |
| Events & Ticketing | Yes — all plans | Yes |
| Embeddable Donation Forms | Yes — all plans | Yes |
| Full Public API | Yes — all plans | Yes |
| Spare Change Round-Ups | Yes — exclusive | Not available |
| NIL Collective Campaign Type | Yes — dedicated type | Not supported |
| Crisis Launch Mode | Under 15 minutes | Not available |
| Tech Team Required? | No — self-serve from day one | Recommended for setup and database management |
SmartChange was deliberately built to be the platform you can hand to anyone on your team — volunteer, board member, first-time organizer — and have them raising money in under 10 minutes. No training. No manual. No implementation consultant.
Bloomerang is powerful, but power comes with complexity. Getting the most out of it means investing real time in database setup, segmentation configuration, and team training. For organizations that have that capacity, it's worth it. For everyone else, it's a barrier.
Bloomerang's monthly subscription starts before your first campaign goes live. SmartChange Standard and Growth have no monthly fees — you pay only when donations come in. When donors cover the processing fee — which 90%+ do — your effective rate drops to 0–1%.
For small nonprofits, volunteer-run organizations, or anyone fundraising for the first time, that difference is the whole conversation.
Bloomerang is genuinely excellent at donor retention — engagement scoring, lapsed donor identification, constituent timelines. If you have a large donor database and dedicated staff to manage it, Bloomerang is built for that job.
SmartChange is built for getting donations in the door — fast, simple, with as little friction as possible for donors and fundraisers alike. These are complementary jobs. Many organizations use both, connected via API.
Bloomerang doesn't offer Spare Change round-ups, a dedicated NIL Collective campaign type, or a crisis launch mode that gets a fundraiser live in under 15 minutes. SmartChange also never prompts donors for tips — it uses donor fee coverage instead, where donors choose to cover the processing fee. Ninety percent do.
SmartChange handles the fundraising: forms, processing, donor experience, real-time giving. Bloomerang handles the relationship: retention scoring, constituent history, long-term stewardship. SmartChange's full public API (on every plan) makes it easy to sync donor data and transactions with Bloomerang in real time. You get the best of both — without paying for features you don't need yet.
Same-day launch. No monthly commitment. No tech team required.
$0 to sign up · No credit card required · Cancel anytime